SELL YOUR SPORTS CARDS & COLLECTIONS
We Buy Vintage Sports Cards from 1900 to 1975
buy + sell + collect
Got Vintage Sports Cards? Let’s Turn Them Into Cash.
Get a Free Evaluation & Lightning-Fast Payment
At Eagle Cards, we make it easy to sell your sports card collection — no matter its size. We specialize in vintage baseball cards and sports collectibles from 1900 to 1975, and we’re always buying. Whether you have a shoebox full of old cardboard or an estate full of binders, we’ll give you a fast, fair review and cash offer — no strings attached.
We work with:
- Retired collectors downsizing their collections
- Families helping a loved one sell their lifetime sports card collection
- Dealers looking to offload inventory
- Anyone who wants to sell vintage sports cards for cash
What Types of Cards Do We Buy?
We’re especially interested in:
- Vintage baseball cards – including T206s, 1933 Goudeys, 1952 Topps, and everything in between
- Early football, basketball, and hockey cards
- Rookie cards of legendary players like Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron, Jackie Robinson, Jim Brown, Wilt Chamberlain, and more
- Cards in high-grade condition, as well as well-loved collections
- Entire sports card collections, estates, or unopened boxes
Even if you're not sure what you have — send us a list or pictures. We'll guide you from there.
Our Simple 3-Step Process:
send photos or a list
Email us or use our contact form to send pictures of your cards or a spreadsheet if you’ve already organized them. Don't worry if it's messy — we can help make sense of it!
get a free review
We’ll assess your collection based on year, condition, scarcity, and market value. Our sports card evaluations are always free, honest, and low-pressure.
get paid fast
Once you accept our offer, you’ll receive payment lightning fast — typically within 24 hours. We pay by Venmo, cash, PayPal, or check, depending on your preference.
Fair Prices. Free REVIEWS. Fast Payment.
Why Eagle Cards?
Cincinnati-based & family-run
No-cost, no-obligation reviews
Fast and straightforward payments
Deep expertise in vintage sports card values
Personalized, honest customer service
Selling Your Sports Cards Has Never Been Easier
You don’t need to be an expert in card grading or auctions — that’s what we’re here for. Whether your cards are mint-condition Mantles or well-loved commons, we’ll treat your collection with the respect it deserves.
Ready to sell? Fill out our
contact form or email us today to get your free sports card review.
Local to Cincinnati? Ask about meeting in person.
Ready to Sell AND Curious What Your Cards Are Worth?
Let’s talk. We offer free evaluations, honest advice, and fair pricing on the spot. If you’re local to Cincinnati or the surrounding region, we’re happy to meet in person. Not local? No problem. We work with sellers nationwide through photos, shipping, and video calls.
Contact us today to learn how easy it is to sell vintage baseball cards and more with Eagle Cards.